A young woman with glasses and her hair in a bun sits at a wooden desk indoors, thoughtfully writing in an open notebook with a pencil.
College Selection

College Search for Student-Athletes: Initial Steps

High school student-athletes who plan to continue playing their chosen sport in college need to start the college search process earlier than most students. It takes time and effort for any student to find the right college fit, and when the athletics piece of the puzzle is in play, the college search can become even more confusing.

​

Perhaps one of the most common mistakes student athletes make in their college search is searching for schools based on the "Athletic Fit" alone. What if you get injured and can't play? You're more than just the sport you play, so your college should be a good fit for you beyond just athletics. Keep in mind that your athletic talent should not be the only factor determining where you'll attend school; treat it instead as a tool to help you gain acceptance to the best overall college fit.

​

As a student-athlete, your final target college list may need to be revised several times before it's complete. Unlike most students, you'll need to go through the college search process twice: first as a student, then as an athlete. Once you've targeted your academic "reach", "middle", and "likely" schools, you'll then need to cross-reference that list with your "Athletic Fit" list.

​

Your search can be further complicated by the (sometimes conflicting) advice you may receive from several sources including your parents, teachers, friends, school counselor, and coaches (high school and AAU). Though these people care about you and have your best interests at heart, they may be suggesting schools that fit only one aspect of you. Listen to those around you, but be sure to always keep focused on the "whole" you.

​

Whether you're a "blue-chip" athlete or the sixth-man off the bench, you need to be proactive in your college search. Don't assume college coaches will find you and initiate contact, as this is often not the case. Due to recruiting budget constraints and NCAA rules and regulations, college coaches are limited in their ability to contact you. It's therefore up to you to promote yourself actively and to initiate contact with college coaches to express your interest in their athletic programs. Keep in mind, however, that it's important that you do your homework before contacting a college coach. It's a waste of your time and the coach's time if a school doesn't actually fit your social, academic, and athletic search criteria. For example, you may fit the academic profile for a Boston College student and you may love the social atmosphere on campus, but are you a Division I-level athlete?

​

  • The 3 Search Criteria a Student-Athlete Should Consider in a College Search
  • Social

​

Know your personality. This is crucial, as it will help match you to a career that you can enjoy for life.

​

Visit many different kinds of college campuses to better determine the basic characteristics you want in a college. Consider characteristics such as size, location, and setting. Nothing can take the place of a college visit; YOU need to walk the campus and get a “feel” for each college.

​

Academic

​

Know your learning style: Are you a student that will do well in a large class setting or do you need more individualized attention?

​

Research potential majors that interest you.

​

Target colleges that offer the class-size that suits you and the potential majors you're considering.

​

Research the academic requirements for each college.

​

Athletic

​

Know your athletic talent level - this is THE first step!

​

Get an honest evaluation of your talent level (Division I, II, or III) from a reputable source who knows the college game.

​

Market yourself to college coaches via letters, email, phone calls, athletic bios, highlight DVDs, camps/showcases/tournaments.

​

Be aware of the NCAA rules and regulations that pertain to your sport.

​

The above information is just a start for student-athletes. After you've compiled your target college list, you'll need to perform a "second-tier" of research that digs deeper into each college's athletic program. This includes reading rosters, pros/cons of athletic scholarships, etc.

​

For a student-athlete, the college search process is a journey full of adventure. Be sure to explore all of your options so that you can make informed decisions. Do your homework and seek out the appropriate help to find the answers you need. It is your future. You're worth it!

​

Kim Penney is an Independent Educational Consultant with One-on-One College Consulting.

​

One-on-One College Consulting guides student-athletes and families through the college admissions and athletic-recruiting process.

​

Website: www.oneononecollegeconsulting.com

<script type="application/ld+json">

{

"@context": "https://schema.org",

"@type": "FAQPage",

"mainEntity": [

{  "@type": "Question",  "name": "What is a common mistake student-athletes make during the college search process?",  "acceptedAnswer": {    "@type": "Answer",    "text": "A common mistake student-athletes make is searching for schools based solely on 'Athletic Fit.' It's important to consider academic and social fit as well, since athletic talent should not be the only factor in choosing a college."  }},{  "@type": "Question",  "name": "Why should student-athletes start the college search process earlier than other students?",  "acceptedAnswer": {    "@type": "Answer",    "text": "Student-athletes should start the college search process earlier because they need to find the right academic, social, and athletic fit, and the process can be more complex due to athletic recruiting and NCAA regulations."  }},{  "@type": "Question",  "name": "What are the three main criteria student-athletes should consider when searching for a college?",  "acceptedAnswer": {    "@type": "Answer",    "text": "Student-athletes should consider social, academic, and athletic criteria when searching for a college. This includes knowing your personality and campus preferences, understanding your learning style and academic interests, and honestly evaluating your athletic talent level."  }},{  "@type": "Question",  "name": "How can student-athletes promote themselves to college coaches?",  "acceptedAnswer": {    "@type": "Answer",    "text": "Student-athletes can promote themselves to college coaches by initiating contact through letters, emails, phone calls, athletic bios, highlight videos, and attending camps or showcases. It's important to research each college to ensure it fits your academic, social, and athletic criteria before reaching out."  }},{  "@type": "Question",  "name": "Why is it important for student-athletes to consider more than just athletics when choosing a college?",  "acceptedAnswer": {    "@type": "Answer",    "text": "It's important because injuries or other circumstances may prevent you from playing your sport, and you are more than just an athlete. Your college should be a good fit for you academically and socially, not just athletically."  }}

]

}

</script>

Keep reading

All articles
Expert Advice
College Selection
03 Sep 2024
2
min read

College Visits: What should I ask?

When doing College Visits, what questions should you ask? What should you look for?

Expert Advice
College Selection
02 Nov 2021
2
min read

What are the most important factors to consider in choosing between small, medium and big schools?

How important is the size of a school? See what College Admissions Experts say are the most important factors to consider in choosing between small and big schools?

Expert Advice
College Selection
08 Mar 2021
2
min read

What Factors Are important to Consider If I Am Thinking of Going to a School Far Away From Home?

For those students thinking about leaving home and travelling out of state for college, what are the important factors to consider?and PSAT, to college admissions webinars and our Ask-An-Expert resource.